At a first meeting, agencies often sound alike: they all talk about strategy, creative and results. The difference shows only in their answers to specific questions. Here are eight questions worth asking before you sign.
Short answer
You can recognise a good agency by how clearly it says who works on your account, how it measures results in enquiries and sales rather than clicks, and whether ad accounts and data stay in your ownership. Before signing, ask for a sample report, a written scope and the exit terms.
1. Who exactly will work on our account?
The founder or director often attends the first meeting, and someone else does the work later. Ask who your point of contact is, who runs the campaigns, who produces the creative and how many clients those people handle at the same time.
2. How do you start, and what do you need from us?
A serious agency wants to understand the goal, past results and constraints before it proposes anything. If you receive a ready-made package after one conversation, and nobody asked what you have tried so far or what your goal is, the plan was probably written for anyone.
3. How do you measure whether marketing works?
Ask them to explain the path from click to sale: which events are tracked, how ad accounts are connected and how cost per customer is calculated. If the answer stops at reach and clicks, you will not know whether the spend pays off. We describe what good measurement looks like in How to measure whether your marketing pays off.
4. Who owns the accounts and the data?
Ad accounts, Google Analytics, the pixel and social pages should be registered to your company, with the agency given access. That way the campaign history and data stay with you if you change agencies. Check that you have admin access to every account.
Accounts and data should stay yours, whoever you work with.
5. What does the report look like, and how often do we get it?
Ask for a sample report without other clients’ data. A good report starts with results against the goal: enquiries, sales, cost per customer. It then explains what was done, what was learned and what comes next. Agree how often you are reported to and what the review meeting looks like.
6. How is the media budget spent and paid?
Clarify the difference between the ad budget and the agency fee. Ask whether the platforms bill you directly or the agency invoices the budget, whether there is a percentage on spend and where you can see actual spend. The answers should be clear before the first campaign.
7. What is in scope, and what is not?
Write down what the agency does each month: the number of campaigns, posts, creatives and meetings. Equally, write down what is not included, such as photography, website development or translation. An “out of scope” list prevents misunderstandings later. You will find a template in From business plan to launch.
8. How does the engagement end?
Ask about the notice period, what happens to the accounts and who owns the creative, copy and footage produced during the engagement. A good contract also covers the handover: access, campaign documentation and materials pass to you without delay.
How to compare two proposals
Proposals can rarely be compared on price alone, because they cover different things. Before you compare, bring them to the same shape:
- The same scope. For each proposal, write down exactly what is included each month and what is not.
- The same cost structure. Separate the agency fee from the ad budget and check whether there is a percentage on spend.
- People, not logos. Compare who actually does the work and how much of their time you get.
- The first 90 days. Ask each agency to describe what it does in the first three months and what you will know at the end of that period that you do not know today.
A proposal that costs more but has a clear measurement plan and leaves the accounts in your ownership is often cheaper than one that does not.
Warning signs
- A guaranteed first place on Google. Google’s own guide says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
- Accounts registered to the agency, without your admin access.
- Reports with only clicks, reach and followers, without enquiries and sales.
- A ready-made package before anyone asked about your goal.
- No clarity on who does the work once the contract is signed.
How we answer these questions
You work with one team lead who is your point of contact. Working together starts with your description of the business and the goal, and we reply with questions or a proposed scope. Every engagement starts with a check of the goal and the tracking. If we are not the right fit for your business, we will tell you and point you elsewhere. Read more about how we work on our Digital marketing page.
In short
Before you sign, find out who does the work, how results are measured, who owns the accounts, what the report looks like, how the budget is spent, what is in scope and how the engagement ends. If you want to put these questions to us too, get in touch.
