A report with thousands of clicks does not tell you whether marketing paid off. Only the link between spend, enquiries and sales does. Here is how to set it up step by step.
Short answer
To know whether marketing pays off, every enquiry and every sale needs a recorded source. Tag your links with UTM parameters, set up key events in Google Analytics 4, connect your ad accounts and track in your CRM which enquiries become customers. Once a month, compare cost per customer with what a customer is worth.
1. Decide what a result is and what it is worth
Before the tools, decide what you measure: a submitted enquiry, a call, a sign-up, a purchase. Then estimate what one such result is worth, starting from the average margin per customer and the share of enquiries that become customers. The method is described in Budget follows the data. Without this value you cannot tell whether a cost per enquiry is good or bad.
2. Tag every link with UTM parameters
UTM parameters are additions at the end of a link that tell Google Analytics where a visitor came from. Google recommends always using three: utm_source (where from, for example newsletter), utm_medium (the type, for example email) and utm_campaign (which campaign). Values are case sensitive, so “Email” and “email” become two different sources. Write down naming rules and stick to them in every campaign.
3. Set up key events in GA4
In Google Analytics 4, the actions that matter to the business are called key events. They used to be called conversions. Mark a submitted form, a click on the phone number and a purchase as key events. All other events stay useful for analysis, but you do not judge channels by them.
4. Connect your ad accounts to measurement
Google Ads can import conversions from Google Analytics, but only events marked as key events in GA4. There are also enhanced conversions, which send hashed data the user entered themselves, such as an email address, to make measurement more accurate.
For Meta ads, in addition to the pixel on your site there is the Conversions API. It sends events from your server directly to Meta, and Meta processes them like pixel events. Less data is lost when a browser blocks cookies.
5. Follow the enquiry through to the sale
For businesses that sell through enquiries, the click and the form are not the end of the road. In your CRM, or at least in a spreadsheet, record the source of every enquiry and whether it became a customer. Google Ads also offers enhanced conversions for leads, which let sales from your CRM flow back into the account and connect to the campaign. Only then does optimisation aim at customers rather than forms.
Judge a channel not by clicks, but by how many customers it brought and at what cost.
6. Read attribution with care
Attribution is the rule that splits credit for a sale between channels. Three models are available in GA4 today: data-driven attribution, paid and organic last click, and Google paid channels last click. The first click, linear, time decay and position-based models were retired in November 2023.
Each ad platform also credits itself by its own rules, so the sum of conversions in your Meta and Google accounts is often higher than the real number of sales. Use the customer count from your CRM or accounts as the check.
7. Allow for cookie consent
Visitors who decline cookies cannot be tracked like everyone else. Google consent mode tells Google tools whether consent was given, and the tools adjust their behaviour. When consent is denied, they send cookieless signals, and Google Analytics fills part of the gaps with modelling. Your numbers will never be complete down to the last enquiry, and that is fine as long as the trend stays comparable.
What to review once a month
- Spend per channel: what went to Meta, Google and other channels.
- Enquiries per channel: how many key events each channel brought.
- Share of enquiries that become customers: per channel, from the CRM.
- Cost per customer: channel spend divided by customers from that channel.
- Comparison with customer value: whether cost per customer is below the margin a customer brings.
Checklist
- The value of one result is written down.
- Every campaign link has utm_source, utm_medium and utm_campaign.
- Form, call and purchase are key events in GA4.
- Google Ads and Meta receive conversions, and the Conversions API or enhanced conversions have been considered.
- The CRM records the source of each enquiry and whether it became a customer.
- The cookie banner and consent mode work together.
In short
Marketing pays off when cost per customer is lower than what a customer is worth, and you can only know that if every step from click to sale is recorded. If you want to set up measurement together, see how we run digital marketing.
